It has to be. Because with people like your WH, there’s no conversation that could ever suffice. There’s nothing that undermines ‘closure’ more than trying to talk with people who re-write history. You end up more wound up and in the end you remind yourself why you had to turn your back to them in the first place.
You're right. And to be clear, when I said "I don't think that's coming," I didn't mean that I need or want a closure conversation with WH2. I'd like to not see or speak to him again. He has no remorse about the way he treated me - as you suggest, he's rewritten history to where I'm a villain and he a victim, so all of this was deserved - and subjecting myself to that would only hurt me.
But I would like to, I don't know, have a sign from the universe that he was a decent person and a good husband who lost his way. I don't believe that anyone in a marriage is blameless or happy 100% of the time, but I thought I was a good wife and that I made him happy for a lot of years. I know his actions and unhappiness over the last 18 months of cheating and whatever mental gymnastics led him there have everything to do with him, his character, his choices and his refusal to communicate, but it's a real killer to the psyche to think that the resentments and bad behavior could have gone much further back. Or that he's convinced himself (as I think he has) that I was emotionally abusive to him for our entire marriage.
I guess that's silly. It's not really going to make me feel better. I'll still feel discarded and used by a pathological liar and emotionally stunted fetish-chaser. Maybe that's the problem? That I feel incredibly stupid for thinking I had a happy marriage with a good and decent man and it turns out I was very, very wrong. Or, to your second point, that I *don't* trust myself anymore.
[This message edited by purplecheetah at 2:41 PM, Thursday, September 17th]